Airbnb dominates the short-term rental market with more listings and bookings than any competitor. VRBO (owned by Expedia) focuses specifically on whole-home vacation rentals and attracts a different guest demographic. Airbnb has more traffic but takes fees from both hosts and guests. VRBO lets hosts collect the full nightly rate but has lower booking volume in most markets. Many successful hosts list on both platforms to maximize occupancy. Neither platform is universally better—your property type, location, and target guest determine which works best.
Fee Structures Compared
| Factor | Airbnb | VRBO |
|---|---|---|
| Host service fee | 3% (split-fee) or 14-16% (host-only) | 5% or 8% (pay-per-booking) |
| Guest service fee | ~14% (split-fee) or 0% (host-only) | 6-12% of booking |
| Annual subscription | None | $499/year option (no per-booking fee) |
| Payment processing | Included | 3% if using VRBO payments |
| On $1,000 booking | Host receives ~$970 (split) or ~$850 (host-only) | Host receives ~$920-950 |
| Cancellation protection | AirCover included | Optional damage protection |
Airbnb's split-fee model (3% host + ~14% guest) is most common. This means hosts receive more per booking, but guests pay more total. VRBO's model puts more fee burden on hosts but can result in lower total cost to guests, potentially increasing booking conversion.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Essential Gear for Side Hustlers
- Dash Cam - Document your work and protect yourself
- Car Phone Charger - Stay connected on the go
- Portable Power Bank - Never run out of battery
- Phone Mount - Hands-free navigation
What to Realistically Expect
- Time required: Both platforms require similar time commitments: responding to inquiries, managing bookings, coordinating cleaning, handling guest communication. Expect 5-15 hours per week for active management of a single property.
- Earnings range: Highly dependent on location, property type, and seasonality. Urban apartments: $15,000-40,000/year gross. Vacation homes in popular areas: $30,000-100,000+/year gross. Deduct 30-50% for expenses, cleaning, and management costs.
- Main tradeoffs: Airbnb has 3-5x more users but more competition. VRBO attracts families booking whole homes with longer average stays and fewer parties. Many hosts list on both to maximize occupancy.
Guest Demographics and Booking Patterns
The platforms attract noticeably different guest profiles:
Typical Airbnb Guest
- • Younger demographic (25-45 core)
- • Mix of solo, couples, and groups
- • Shorter stays (2-5 nights average)
- • Open to shared spaces, unique properties
- • Price-sensitive, compares multiple listings
- • Higher booking volume, more inquiries
Typical VRBO Guest
- • Older demographic (35-60 core)
- • Families and multi-generational groups
- • Longer stays (5-10 nights average)
- • Prefers whole-home properties only
- • Less price-sensitive, values space
- • Lower volume but larger bookings
If you have a whole home suitable for families in a vacation destination, VRBO guests may be your ideal audience. If you have an urban apartment or unique space, Airbnb's broader user base provides more booking opportunities.
Best Property Types for Each Platform
Airbnb Strengths
- • Urban apartments: Business travelers and city tourists use Airbnb as default
- • Unique/quirky properties: Treehouses, tiny homes, converted spaces get visibility
- • Shared spaces: Private rooms in homes work on Airbnb; VRBO is whole-homes only
- • International properties: Airbnb has stronger global presence
- • Experience-focused stays: Airbnb markets "experiences" beyond just accommodation
VRBO Strengths
- • Beach/mountain vacation homes: Traditional vacation rental market is VRBO's core
- • Large homes (4+ bedrooms): Families booking for reunions prefer VRBO
- • Lake houses, cabins: Second-home vacation properties perform well
- • Ski condos: Resort destinations have strong VRBO presence
- • Properties wanting fewer but longer bookings: Less turnover, more predictable
Common Pitfalls
Only listing on one platform
Unless your calendar is consistently 80%+ full on one platform, you're leaving money on the table. Most successful hosts list on both Airbnb and VRBO (and sometimes Booking.com). Use channel management software to sync calendars and avoid double-bookings.
Ignoring platform-specific optimization
Each platform has different search algorithms. Airbnb rewards quick response time, low rejection rates, and review velocity. VRBO emphasizes complete listings, calendar accuracy, and return guests. Optimize your listing strategy for each platform separately.
Underestimating total costs
Platform fees are just the start. Factor in cleaning (often $100-300+ per turnover), supplies replenishment, maintenance, utilities (short-term rentals use more), insurance gap coverage, and potential property management fees (20-30% if outsourced). True net income is often 50-60% of gross revenue.
Not understanding local regulations
Many cities have short-term rental restrictions: permits, occupancy limits, minimum stay requirements, or outright bans. Fines can be $1,000+ per violation. Research local laws before listing. Some hosts have been forced to delist entirely after years of operation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I list on both Airbnb and VRBO?
Yes, and most successful hosts do. You'll need to manage calendars carefully to avoid double-bookings. Channel management tools (Lodgify, Guesty, Hospitable) can sync availability across platforms automatically. The effort is worth it for increased booking potential.
Which platform has better guest quality?
VRBO guests tend to be families on planned vacations—generally more respectful of properties. Airbnb's broader user base includes more party-risk groups (bachelor/bachelorette parties, local bookings). Neither platform is immune to problem guests, but VRBO's demographic skews lower-risk.
What about Booking.com?
Booking.com is the third major platform, especially strong for international guests and hotel alternatives. Commission is typically 15%. Consider adding it if you're in a tourist destination with international visitors. The interface is more hotel-centric but vacation rentals perform well.
Which has better host protection?
Airbnb's AirCover includes $3 million damage protection and liability coverage at no extra cost. VRBO offers optional damage protection but it's not as comprehensive. For high-value properties, consider additional short-term rental insurance regardless of platform coverage.
How do I price my listing?
Research comparable listings in your area on both platforms. Consider using dynamic pricing tools (PriceLabs, Beyond, Wheelhouse) that adjust rates based on demand, events, and seasonality. Don't set it and forget it—active pricing management can increase revenue 10-30%.
Should I require minimum stays?
Depends on your property and goals. Longer minimums (3-7 nights) reduce turnover costs and attract vacation renters. Shorter minimums maximize occupancy in urban markets. VRBO guests naturally book longer stays. Many hosts use different minimums for weekdays vs. weekends and peak vs. off-season.
How important are reviews?
Critical on both platforms. New listings with no reviews get buried in search. Superhost (Airbnb) and Premier Host (VRBO) status unlock visibility benefits. Your first 5-10 reviews set the tone. Consider offering slight discounts to early guests to build momentum, then raise prices once established.
Related Guides
What Airbnb Hosts Actually Earn
Real numbers after all expenses and fees.
Passive Income Time Investment
How much work "passive" income really requires.
Is Starting a Business Worth It?
Time and money reality of running a rental business.
Side Hustle vs Part-Time Job
Comparing rental hosting to traditional employment.